Dr. Mitchell Stargrove, a naturopathic physician and homeopathic practitioner active online, described some of the main differences and similarities between these types of alternative treatments. It is important to note that this information does not take the place of medical diagnosis, nor does it imply any recommendation by CompuServe or CompuServeCD. Rather, it is intended to provide information about a form of health care that may unfamiliar to some subscribers. In-depth information and threads from experts in the field may be found in Holistic Health Forum, Herbs section. Files that may be of interest include HERBFRM.TXT and 50HERB.TXT.
1. What do you use herbs for?
Herbs are used in three ways: to treat a problem (palliative), to prevent a problem (preventative), and to nourish as a tonic does. For example, you might use chamomile or ginger for an upset stomach, perhaps in a tea or infusion; these work in a biochemical way. Ginseng, on the other hand, might be taken before a menstrual period, to "build up" the vital energy.
Some herbalists focus on the biochemicstry of the plant, while others focus on the character and quality associated with the plant. Herbs work based on a nutritional effect, such as the ginseng example, or through a biochemical, curative action, such as chamomile.
2. What is homeopathy?
Homeopathy is a method of health care that works on the Principle of Similars. This principle suggests that a compound which causes an effect in large doses will cure a sick person with those symptoms in an infinitesimal dose. For example, if coffee keeps you awake, minute doses of caffeine can cure insomnia and anxiety. This approach was suggested in the late eighteenth century by the German physician, Samuel Hahneman.
3. Are there any dangers associated with herbal and homeopathic medicines?
Both herbs and homeopathics can be misused. Herbs or homeopathic remedies can be mixed with others for harmful effects, can be taken too often, or can suppress an illness. Mixing homeopathic medicines can suppress an illness, or make it difficult for the practitioner to assist in prescribing, especially for chronic ailments. Some herbs, such as Ma Huang and senna, should not be taken by all people and a knowledgeable health care professional should be consulted.
4. Is there anyone for whom homeopathy is dangerous?
While pregnant and nursing women should always take care when self administering medicines, homeopaths point out that the amount of substances is so small, even children may take homeopathic medicines . This is not the case with all herbal remedies, however.
